Skip to content
Image

Columbus Crew vs St. Louis CITY SC, St. Louis CITY SC win 5-3 on penalties

U.S. Open Cup
Columbus
CLB
0-0
Final/Pens
St. Louis
STL
St. Louis CITY SC win 5-3 on penalties
ScottsMiracle-Gro Field

Match pulse

CLBAttacking pressure by 5 minutes
0'HTSTL
50%Possession50%
16Shots5
3On target3
5Corners2
3Saves3
23Fouls22
82'Santiago RodríguezCLB90'+10'Carlo HolseSTL90'+12'Daniel EdelmanSTL104'Tomas TotlandSTL119'Eric BaillyCLB
Team1H2HET1ET2PKT
CLB000030
STL000050

Who won: St. Louis 0-0

St. Louis CITY SC beat Columbus Crew 0-0 on penalties in St. Louis CITY SC win 5-3 on penalties on Wednesday, October 21, 2026 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.

Every player rated

Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0
  1. 17.7Nicholas HagenG
  2. 27.7Roman BürkiG
  3. 36.5Sean ZawadzkiCD
  4. 46.5Anass ZarouryLM
  5. 56.4Malte AmundsenCD-L
  6. 66.4Lukas MacNaughtonCD-R
  7. 76.3Mohamed FarsiRM
  8. 86.3Brais MéndezCF-R
  9. 96.3Dante PolvaraCD-L
  10. 106.2Timo BaumgartlCD
  11. 116.2Simon BecherF
  12. 126.2Jeong Sang-BinCF-R

Team stats

CLBSTL
23Fouls22
2Yellow Cards3
0Red Cards0
0Offsides3
5Corner Kicks2
3Saves3
50.1Possession49.9
16SHOTS5
3ON GOAL3
0.2On Target %0.6
0Penalty Goals0
0Penalty Kicks Taken0
416Accurate Passes427
516Passes523
0.8Pass Completion %0.8
0Accurate Crosses0
0Crosses0
0.0Cross %0.0
0Long Balls0
0Accurate Long Balls0
0.0Long Balls %0.0
8Blocked Shots1
16Effective Tackles17
19Tackles25
0.8Tackle %0.7
0Interceptions0
0Effective Clearances0
31Clearances26

Player of the game

Nicholas Hagen

CLB · 3 saves, clean sheet

7.7

Play by play

  1. SCORE127'
    Daniel Edelman

    Daniel Edelman (St. Louis CITY SC) Penalty - Scored at 127'

    Daniel Edelman

    CLB 3 - 5 STL
  2. SCORE126'

    Andrés Herrera (Columbus Crew) Penalty - Scored at 126'

    Andrés Herrera

    CLB 3 - 4 STL
  3. SCORE125'

    Damion Downs (St. Louis CITY SC) Penalty - Scored at 125'

    Damion Downs

    CLB 2 - 4 STL
  4. SCORE125'

    Gonzalo Tapia (Columbus Crew) Penalty - Scored at 125'

    Gonzalo Tapia

    CLB 2 - 3 STL
  5. SCORE124'
    Christopher Durkin

    Christopher Durkin (St. Louis CITY SC) Penalty - Scored at 124'

    Christopher Durkin

    CLB 1 - 3 STL
  6. SCORE123'
    Malte Amundsen

    Malte Amundsen (Columbus Crew) Penalty - Scored at 123'

    Malte Amundsen

    CLB 1 - 2 STL
  7. SCORE122'
    Lukas MacNaughton

    Lukas MacNaughton (St. Louis CITY SC) Penalty - Scored at 122'

    Lukas MacNaughton

    CLB 0 - 2 STL
  8. 122'Santiago Rodríguez

    Penalty - missed

    Santiago Rodríguez (Columbus Crew) Penalty - Missed at 122'

  9. SCORE121'
    Timo Baumgartl

    Timo Baumgartl (St. Louis CITY SC) Penalty - Scored at 121'

    Timo Baumgartl

    CLB 0 - 1 STL
  10. 119'

    Yellow card

    Eric Bailly (Columbus Crew) Yellow Card at 119'

    E. Bailly

  11. 113'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Andrés Herrera (Columbus Crew) Substitution at 113'

    A. Herrera

  12. 105'Tomas Ostrak
    Sub

    Substitution

    Tomas Ostrak (St. Louis CITY SC) Substitution at 105'

    T. Ostrak

  13. 104'

    Yellow card

    Tomas Totland (St. Louis CITY SC) Yellow Card at 104'

    T. Totland

  14. 90'+12'Daniel Edelman

    Yellow card

    Daniel Edelman (St. Louis CITY SC) Yellow Card at 90'+12'

    D. Edelman

  15. 90'+10'

    Yellow card

    Carlo Holse (St. Louis CITY SC) Yellow Card at 90'+10'

    C. Holse

  16. 90'+1'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Eric Bailly (Columbus Crew) Substitution at 90'+1'

    E. Bailly

  17. 84'Brooks Lennon
    Sub

    Substitution

    Brooks Lennon (Columbus Crew) Substitution at 84'

    B. Lennon

  18. 84'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Sékou Tidiany Bangoura (Columbus Crew) Substitution at 84'

    S. Bangoura

  19. 82'Santiago Rodríguez

    Yellow card

    Santiago Rodríguez (Columbus Crew) Yellow Card at 82'

    S. Rodríguez

  20. 78'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Damion Downs (St. Louis CITY SC) Substitution at 78'

    D. Downs

  21. 78'Benjamin Lundt
    Sub

    Substitution

    Benjamin Lundt (St. Louis CITY SC) Substitution at 78'

    B. Lundt

  22. 68'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Gonzalo Tapia (Columbus Crew) Substitution at 68'

    G. Tapia

Leaders

CLBSTL
Total Shots
Brais Méndez
4
Conrad Wallem
1
Accurate Passes
Sean Zawadzki
57
Timo Baumgartl
60
Defensive Interventions
Steven Moreira
7
Dante Polvara
13
Saves
Nicholas Hagen
3
Roman Bürki
3

Season seriesCLB leads series 2-0