Skip to content

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC, Columbus Crew advance 4-3 on penalties

U.S. Open Cup
1-1
Final/Pens
Columbus Crew advance 4-3 on penalties
ScottsMiracle-Gro Field

Match pulse

CLBAttacking pressure by 5 minutes
0'HTNYC
53%Possession47%
18Shots5
6On target3
7Corners5
2Saves5
3Fouls16
26'Christian McFarlaneNYC88'Santiago RodríguezNYC
Team1H2HET1ET2PKT
CLB100041
NYC100031

Who won: Columbus 1-1

Columbus Crew beat New York City FC 1-1 on penalties in Columbus Crew advance 4-3 on penalties on Saturday, August 17, 2024 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field. Goals for Columbus: Cucho Hernández (41'). Goals for NYCFC: Alonso Martínez (1').

Every player rated

Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0
  1. 17.7Cucho HernándezF
  2. 27.2Alonso MartínezF
  3. 37.1Matt FreeseG
  4. 46.7Max ArfstenLM
  5. 56.6Diego RossiCF-L
  6. 66.3Christian RamírezCF-R
  7. 76.2Patrick SchulteG
  8. 86.2Darlington NagbeCM-L
  9. 96.2Thiago MartinsCD-R
  10. 106.1Steven MoreiraCD-R
  11. 116.1Sean ZawadzkiCM-R
  12. 126.1Mohamed FarsiRM

Team stats

CLBNYC
3Fouls16
0Yellow Cards2
0Red Cards0
3Offsides1
7Corner Kicks5
2Saves5
52.8Possession47.2
18SHOTS5
6ON GOAL3
0.3On Target %0.6
0Penalty Goals0
0Penalty Kicks Taken0
442Accurate Passes364
506Passes450
0.9Pass Completion %0.8
4Accurate Crosses3
18Crosses12
0.2Cross %0.3
42Long Balls36
21Accurate Long Balls11
0.5Long Balls %0.3
4Blocked Shots1
9Effective Tackles6
12Tackles10
0.8Tackle %0.6
15Interceptions10
11Effective Clearances12
11Clearances12

Player of the game

Cucho Hernández

CLB · 1 G

7.7

Deserved to win

15%
CLB · 0.17 xG
81%
Draw
5%
NYC · 0.05 xG

Columbus deserved better: 15% on chances, drew 1-1

Play by play

  1. Match ends, Columbus Crew 1(4), New York City FC 1(3).
  2. 98'

    Penalty Shootout ends, Columbus Crew 1(4), New York City FC 1(3).

  3. GOAL98'
    DeJuan Jones

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(4), New York City FC 1(3). DeJuan Jones (Columbus Crew) converts...

    DeJuan Jones

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(4), New York City FC 1(3). DeJuan Jones (Columbus Crew) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the top right corner.

    CLB 5 - 4 NYC
  4. 97'Santiago Rodríguez

    Penalty - missed

    Penalty missed. Santiago Rodríguez (New York City FC) right footed shot is just a bit too high.

  5. GOAL96'
    Cucho Hernández

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(3), New York City FC 1(3). Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew)...

    Cucho Hernández

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(3), New York City FC 1(3). Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the high centre of the goal.

    CLB 4 - 4 NYC
  6. GOAL96'
    James Sands

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(2), New York City FC 1(3). James Sands (New York City FC)...

    James Sands

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(2), New York City FC 1(3). James Sands (New York City FC) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the top left corner.

    CLB 3 - 4 NYC
  7. 95'Diego Rossi

    Penalty - missed

    Penalty saved. Diego Rossi (Columbus Crew) right footed shot saved in the bottom right corner.

  8. 94'NYC

    Penalty - missed

    Penalty saved. Maximiliano Moralez (New York City FC) right footed shot saved in the bottom left corner.

  9. GOAL93'
    Jacen Russell-Rowe

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(2), New York City FC 1(2). Jacen Russell-Rowe (Columbus Crew)...

    Jacen Russell-Rowe

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(2), New York City FC 1(2). Jacen Russell-Rowe (Columbus Crew) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the bottom left corner.

    CLB 3 - 3 NYC
  10. GOAL92'
    NYC

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(1), New York City FC 1(2). Mounsef Bakrar (New York City FC)...

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(1), New York City FC 1(2). Mounsef Bakrar (New York City FC) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the centre of the goal.

    CLB 2 - 3 NYC
  11. GOAL91'
    Rudy Camacho

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(1), New York City FC 1(1). Rudy Camacho (Columbus Crew) converts...

    Rudy Camacho

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1(1), New York City FC 1(1). Rudy Camacho (Columbus Crew) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the top left corner.

    CLB 2 - 2 NYC
  12. GOAL91'
    Thiago Martins

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1, New York City FC 1(1). Thiago Martins (New York City FC)...

    Thiago Martins

    Goal! Columbus Crew 1, New York City FC 1(1). Thiago Martins (New York City FC) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the bottom left corner.

    CLB 1 - 2 NYC
  13. 90'

    Penalty Shootout begins Columbus Crew 1, New York City FC 1.

  14. Second Half ends, Columbus Crew 1, New York City FC 1.
  15. 90'+7'James Sands

    Free kick won

    James Sands (New York City FC) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  16. 90'+7'Cucho Hernández

    Foul

    Foul by Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew).

  17. 90'+5'Steven Moreira

    Shot off target

    Attempt missed. Steven Moreira (Columbus Crew) right footed shot from outside the box is too high. Assisted by DeJuan Jones.

  18. 90'+4'Diego Rossi

    Shot off target

    Attempt missed. Diego Rossi (Columbus Crew) right footed shot from the right side of the six yard box misses to the left. Assisted by Mohamed Farsi.

  19. 90'+3'Mohamed Farsi

    Free kick won

    Mohamed Farsi (Columbus Crew) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  20. 90'+3'NYC

    Foul

    Foul by Maximiliano Moralez (New York City FC).

  21. 90'+2'Mitja Ilenic
    Sub

    Subbed on for T. Gray

    Substitution, New York City FC. Mitja Ilenic replaces Tayvon Gray.

    M. Ilenic

  22. 90'+2'

    Delay over. They are ready to continue.

  23. 90'+1'Tayvon Gray

    Delay in match because of an injury Tayvon Gray (New York City FC).

  24. 90'Steven Moreira

    Corner awarded

    Corner, New York City FC. Conceded by Steven Moreira.

  25. 88'Cucho Hernández

    Free kick

    Attempt missed. Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses the top right corner from a direct free kick.

Leaders

CLBNYC
Total Shots
Cucho Hernández
8
Alonso Martínez
2
Saves
Patrick Schulte
2
Matt Freese
5

Ask about this game