Skip to content

New York City FC vs Columbus Crew

U.S. Open Cup
NYCFC
15-9-10
4-1
Final
Columbus
8-12-14
Yankee Stadium

Match pulse

NYCAttacking pressure by 5 minutes
0'HTCLB
49%Possession52%
12Shots15
6On target6
2Corners6
5Saves2
13Fouls12
25'Maxime ChanotNYC79'Tony TchaniCLB
Team1H2HT
NYC134
CLB011

Who won: NYCFC 4-1

New York City FC beat Columbus Crew 4-1 on Sunday, October 23, 2016 at Yankee Stadium. Goals for NYCFC: Stiven Mendoza (45'), Jack Harrison (75'), Khiry Shelton (77') and David Villa (90'+3'). Goals for Columbus: Ola Kamara (59').

Every player rated

Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0
  1. 18.4David VillaCF-L
  2. 28.0Jack HarrisonCF-R
  3. 37.7Eirik JohansenG
  4. 47.5Stiven MendozaAM
  5. 56.6Frank LampardSUB
  6. 66.5Khiry SheltonSUB
  7. 76.5Justin MeramAM-L
  8. 86.4Andoni IraolaCD
  9. 96.3Frédéric BrillantCD-R
  10. 106.3Rónald MatarritaLM
  11. 116.3Ola KamaraF
  12. 126.2RJ AllenRM

Team stats

NYCCLB
13Fouls12
1Yellow Cards1
0Red Cards0
1Offsides9
2Corner Kicks6
5Saves2
48.5Possession51.5
12SHOTS15
6ON GOAL6
0.5On Target %0.4
0Penalty Goals0
0Penalty Kicks Taken0
346Accurate Passes364
445Passes461
0.8Pass Completion %0.8
4Accurate Crosses5
16Crosses26
0.3Cross %0.2
47Long Balls67
26Accurate Long Balls35
0.6Long Balls %0.5
3Blocked Shots5
17Effective Tackles12
23Tackles22
0.7Tackle %0.5
0Interceptions0
20Effective Clearances15
24Clearances19

Player of the game

David Villa

NYC · 1 G, 1 A

8.4

Deserved to win

10%
NYC · 0.12 xG
78%
Draw
12%
CLB · 0.15 xG

Dead even on chances: this one could have gone either way

Play by play

  1. Second Half ends, New York City FC 4, Columbus Crew SC 1.
  2. GOAL90'+3'
    David Villa

    Goal! Right footed shot

    D. Villa · ast F. Lampard

    Goal! New York City FC 4, Columbus Crew SC 1. David Villa (New York City FC) right footed shot from outside the box to the top right corner. Assisted by Frank Lampard.

    NYC 4 - 1 CLB
  3. 90'+2'Maxime Chanot

    Corner awarded

    Corner, Columbus Crew SC. Conceded by Maxime Chanot.

  4. 90'+1'

    Free kick won

    Tony Tchani (Columbus Crew SC) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  5. 90'+1'RJ Allen

    Foul

    Foul by RJ Allen (New York City FC).

  6. 88'

    Delay over. They are ready to continue.

  7. 88'

    Delay in match Federico Bravo (New York City FC) because of an injury.

  8. 84'NYC

    Corner awarded

    Corner, Columbus Crew SC. Conceded by Ronald Matarrita.

  9. 82'Jason Hernandez
    Sub

    Subbed on for J. Harrison

    Substitution, New York City FC. Jason Hernandez replaces Jack Harrison.

    J. Hernandez

  10. 81'

    Handball

    Hand ball by Frank Lampard (New York City FC).

  11. 79'

    Foul

    Foul by Tony Tchani (Columbus Crew SC).

  12. 79'

    Free kick won

    Andoni Iraola (New York City FC) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  13. 79'

    Yellow card

    Tony Tchani (Columbus Crew SC) is shown the yellow card.

    T. Tchani

  14. 78'Justin Meram

    Free kick won

    Justin Meram (Columbus Crew SC) wins a free kick on the left wing.

  15. 78'

    Foul

    Foul by Federico Bravo (New York City FC).

  16. GOAL77'
    Khiry Shelton

    Goal! Right footed shot

    K. Shelton · ast J. Harrison

    Goal! New York City FC 3, Columbus Crew SC 1. Khiry Shelton (New York City FC) right footed shot from outside the box to the bottom left corner. Assisted by Jack Harrison following a fast break.

    NYC 3 - 1 CLB
  17. 76'
    Sub

    Subbed on for F. Higuaín

    Substitution, Columbus Crew SC. Conor Casey replaces Federico Higuaín.

    C. Casey

  18. GOAL75'

    Goal! Left footed shot

    J. Harrison · ast F. Lampard

    Goal! New York City FC 2, Columbus Crew SC 1. Jack Harrison (New York City FC) left footed shot from the centre of the box to the top left corner. Assisted by Frank Lampard.

    NYC 2 - 1 CLB
  19. 74'Justin Meram

    Left footed shot just wide

    Attempt missed. Justin Meram (Columbus Crew SC) left footed shot from the left side of the box is just a bit too high. Assisted by Tony Tchani.

    J. Meram

  20. 73'
    Sub

    Subbed on for A. Pirlo

    Substitution, New York City FC. Frank Lampard replaces Andrea Pirlo.

    F. Lampard

  21. 72'Justin Meram

    Offside

    Offside, Columbus Crew SC. Michael Parkhurst tries a through ball, but Justin Meram is caught offside.

  22. 70'NYC

    Corner awarded

    Corner, New York City FC. Conceded by Brad Stuver.

  23. 70'David Villa

    Shot on target

    Attempt saved. David Villa (New York City FC) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Andrea Pirlo.

  24. 68'RJ Allen

    Free kick won

    RJ Allen (New York City FC) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  25. 68'Wil Trapp

    Foul

    Foul by Wil Trapp (Columbus Crew SC).

Leaders

NYCCLB
Total Shots
David Villa
6
Federico Higuaín
4
Accurate Passes
Maxime Chanot
62
Tony Tchani
63
Saves
Eirik Johansen
6
Brad Stuver
2