Butler Bulldogs vs St. Thomas-Minnesota Tommies

College Football

Butler

4-2

21-14

Final/OT

St Thomas (MN)

2-3

O'Shaughnessy Stadium

Drive chart

Drives

Missed FG
Missed FG
Touchdown
Fumble
Downs
Punt

Team	1	2	3	4	OT	T
BUT	7	7	0	0	7	21
STMN	7	0	0	7	0	14

Who won: Butler 21-14

The Butler Bulldogs beat the St. Thomas-Minnesota Tommies 21-14 in overtime on Saturday, October 4, 2025 at O'Shaughnessy Stadium. Reagan Andrew led the Butler in passing yards (16/21, 141 YDS). Andy Peters led the St Thomas (MN) in passing yards (16/27, 193 YDS, 1 TD, 2 INT).

Player of the game

Reagan Andrew

BUT · 16/21, 141 YDS, 3 RUSH TD

8.7

Win probability

100%BUT final

BUTSTMN

Tap or hover the line to see the play. Dots mark the biggest swings.

Play by play

Q4 0:16STM
Rush
Gabriel Abel run for 3 yds to the BUT 21
1st & 10 at BTLR 24
Q4 0:16STM
24 yd completion
Andy Peters pass complete to JaShawn Todd for 24 yds to the BUT 24 for a 1ST down
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at BTLR 48
Q4 1:51STM
Pass reception
Andy Peters pass complete to Eli Paulson for 10 yds to the BUT 48 for a 1ST down
1st & 10 at STMN 42
Q4 1:51STM
10 yd completion
Andy Peters pass complete to JaShawn Todd for 10 yds to the STMN 42 for a 1ST down
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at STMN 32
Q4 1:51STM
Rush
Andy Peters run for 7 yds to the STMN 32 for a 1ST down
3rd & 5 at STMN 25
Q4 1:51STM
Rush
Gabriel Abel run for 2 yds to the STMN 25
2nd & 7 at STMN 23
Q4 1:51STM
3 yd run
Gabriel Abel run for 3 yds to the STMN 23
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at STMN 20
Q4 1:51BUT
29 yd field goal missed
Ryan Short 29 yd FG MISSED
4th & 3 · 4th & 3 at STMN 11
Q4 2:00BUT
Stuffed for a loss of 1
Reagan Andrew run for a loss of 1 yard to the STMN 11
3rd & 2 · 3rd & 2 at STMN 10
Q4 10:10BUT
4 yd run
Reagan Andrew run for 4 yds to the STMN 10
2nd & 6 · 2nd & 6 at STMN 14
Q4 10:10BUT
Pass reception
Reagan Andrew pass complete to Brady Preston for 4 yds to the STMN 14
1st & 10 at STMN 18
Q4 10:10BUT
1 yd run
Reagan Andrew run for 1 yd to the STMN 18 for a 1ST down
3rd & 1 · 3rd & 1 at STMN 19
Q4 10:10BUT
2 yd run
Reagan Andrew run for 2 yds to the STMN 19
2nd & 3 · 2nd & 3 at STMN 21
Q4 10:10BUT
7 yd run
Reagan Andrew run for 7 yds to the STMN 21
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at STMN 28
Q4 10:10BUT
Incomplete
Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Chet Yardley for a 1ST down St. Thomas-Minnesota Penalty, Defensive pass interference (Branden Smith) to the STMN 28 for a 1ST down
3rd & 8 · 3rd & 8 at STMN 36
Q4 10:10BUT
2 yd completion
Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Malafa for a loss of 2 yards to the STMN 36
2nd & 6 · 2nd & 6 at STMN 34
Q4 10:10BUT
4 yd completion
Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Loss for 4 yds to the STMN 34
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at STMN 38
Q4 10:10BUT
15 yd run
Reagan Andrew run for 15 yds to the STMN 38 for a 1ST down
2nd & 10 · 2nd & 10 at BTLR 47
Q4 10:10BUT
No gain on the run
Reagan Andrew run for no gain to the BUT 47
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at BTLR 47
Q4 10:10BUT
11 yd completion
Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Malafa for 11 yds to the BUT 47 for a 1ST down
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at BTLR 36
Q4 10:10BUT
5 yd run
Reagan Andrew run for 5 yds to the BUT 36 for a 1ST down
2nd & 4 · 2nd & 4 at BTLR 31
Q4 10:10BUT
6 yd run
Gabe Passini run for 6 yds to the BUT 31
1st & 10 · 1st & 10 at BTLR 25
Q4 10:10STM
Kickoff, touchback
Elliot Huether kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
TOUCHDOWNQ4 10:10
STM
Touchdown! 1 yd run
Andy Peters run for 1 yd for a TD (Ben Hoiland KICK)
BUT 14 - 14 STMN
Q4 15:00STM
No gain on the run
Andy Peters run for no gain to the BUT 1
2nd & Goal · 2nd & Goal at BTLR 1