Skip to content

Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders

NHL
Maple Leafs
19-15-7, 45 PTS
3-4
Final/OT
Islanders
23-15-4, 50 PTS
UBS Arena

On the ice

TOR shoots leftNYI shoots right

Shots on goal

1st2nd3rdOTT
TOR7113021
NYI7610225

In net

Joseph Woll21/25 SV, .840
David Rittich18/21 SV, .857
Team123OTT
TOR02103
NYI01214

Who won: Islanders 4-3

The New York Islanders beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 in overtime on Saturday, January 3, 2026 at UBS Arena. Matthew Schaefer led the Islanders in goals (2). Auston Matthews led the Maple Leafs in goals (2).

Every player rated

Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0
  1. 18.4Matthew SchaeferD
  2. 28.2Auston MatthewsC
  3. 37.8Mathew BarzalC
  4. 47.8Jonathan DrouinLW
  5. 57.7Emil HeinemanLW
  6. 67.7Adam PelechD
  7. 77.6Tony DeAngeloD
  8. 87.4Jean-Gabriel PageauC
  9. 97.2Nick RobertsonLW
  10. 107.1Simon HolmstromRW
  11. 117.0Nicolas RoyC
  12. 126.8Jake McCabeD

Team stats

TORNYI
11Blocked Shots11
19Hits21
2Takeaways6
21Shots25
0Power Play Goals0
1Power Play Opportunities1
0.0Power Play Percentage0.0
0Short Handed Goals0
0Shootout Goals0
32Faceoffs Won24
57.1Faceoff Win Percent42.9
19Giveaways17
2Total Penalties2
4Penalty Minutes4

Player of the game

Matthew Schaefer

NYI · 2 G, 2 SOG

8.4

Deserved to win

53%
TOR · 2.47 xG
47%
NYI · 2.35 xG

Maple Leafs deserved better: 53% on chances, lost 3-4

Play by play

  1. End of the overtime
  2. GOALOT 4:11
    Matthew Schaefer

    Goal! Snap shot

    M. Schaefer · 2 G

    Matthew Schaefer Goal (12) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (22), Emil Heineman (7)

    TOR 3 - 4 NYI
  3. OT 3:52Tony DeAngelo

    Wrist shot on goal

    Tony DeAngelo Wrist Shot saved by Joseph Woll

    T. DeAngelo · 1 A

  4. OT 2:06Auston Matthews

    Shot blocked by J. Drouin

    Auston Matthews shot blocked by Jonathan Drouin

    A. Matthews · 2 G

  5. OT 1:38Matthew Knies

    Snap shot wide left

    Matthew Knies Snap Shot Wide Left

    M. Knies

  6. OT 1:05Matias Maccelli

    Tip-in wide left

    Matias Maccelli Tip-In Wide Left

    M. Maccelli

  7. OT 0:00John Tavares

    Faceoff win vs M. Barzal

    John Tavares faceoff won against Mathew Barzal

    J. Tavares

  8. Start of the overtime
  9. End of the 3rd period
  10. P3 0:25Anders Lee
    TO

    Giveaway

    Giveaway by Anders Lee

    A. Lee

  11. P3 0:33Scott Laughton

    Snap shot on goal

    Scott Laughton Snap Shot saved by David Rittich

    S. Laughton

  12. P3 0:53Morgan Rielly
    TO

    Giveaway

    Giveaway by Morgan Rielly

  13. P3 1:00Max Domi

    Shot blocked by M. Barzal

    Max Domi shot blocked by Mathew Barzal

    M. Domi · 1 A

  14. P3 2:02Troy Stecher

    Shot blocked by M. Gatcomb

    Troy Stecher shot blocked by Marc Gatcomb

    T. Stecher

  15. P3 2:27Troy Stecher

    Shot blocked by A. Pelech

    Troy Stecher shot blocked by Adam Pelech

    T. Stecher

  16. P3 2:45Casey Cizikas

    Faceoff win vs J. Tavares

    Casey Cizikas faceoff won against John Tavares

    C. Cizikas

  17. GOALP3 2:45
    Emil Heineman

    Goal! Snap shot

    E. Heineman · 1 G, 1 A

    Emil Heineman Goal (13) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (21), Tony DeAngelo (13)

    TOR 3 - 3 NYI
  18. P3 3:47Simon Benoit

    Big hit on C. Cizikas

    Simon Benoit hit Casey Cizikas

    S. Benoit

  19. P3 4:14Marc Gatcomb

    Big hit on M. Rielly

    Marc Gatcomb hit Morgan Rielly

    M. Gatcomb

  20. P3 4:49Matthew Schaefer

    Big hit on J. Tavares

    Matthew Schaefer hit John Tavares

    M. Schaefer · 2 G

  21. P3 5:23Tony DeAngelo

    Shot blocked by B. McMann

    Tony DeAngelo shot blocked by Bobby McMann

    T. DeAngelo · 1 A

  22. P3 5:42Simon Benoit

    Big hit on J. Drouin

    Simon Benoit hit Jonathan Drouin

    S. Benoit

  23. P3 5:45Auston Matthews
    TO

    Giveaway

    Giveaway by Auston Matthews

    A. Matthews · 2 G

  24. P3 5:52Jean-Gabriel Pageau

    Big hit on M. Benning

    Jean-Gabriel Pageau hit Matthew Benning

    J. Pageau · 1 A

  25. P3 5:52Adam Pelech

    Wrist shot wide left

    Adam Pelech Wrist Shot Wide Left

    A. Pelech · 1 G

Leaders

TORNYI
Goals
Auston Matthews
2
Matthew Schaefer
2
Assists
Max Domi
1
Mathew Barzal
2
Points
Auston Matthews
2
Matthew Schaefer
2

Ask about this game