Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders
On the ice
Shots on goal
| 1st | 2nd | 3rd | OT | T | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TOR | 7 | 11 | 3 | 0 | 21 |
| NYI | 7 | 6 | 10 | 2 | 25 |
In net
Who won: Islanders 4-3
The New York Islanders beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 in overtime on Saturday, January 3, 2026 at UBS Arena. Matthew Schaefer led the Islanders in goals (2). Auston Matthews led the Maple Leafs in goals (2).
Every player rated
Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0- 18.4
Matthew SchaeferD2 PTS2 G - 28.2
Auston MatthewsC2 PTS2 G - 37.8
Mathew BarzalC2 PTS2 A - 47.8
Jonathan DrouinLW2 PTS2 A - 57.7
Emil HeinemanLW2 PTS1 G1 A - 67.7
Adam PelechD1 PTS1 G - 77.6
Tony DeAngeloD1 PTS1 A - 87.4
Jean-Gabriel PageauC1 PTS1 A - 97.2
Nick RobertsonLW1 PTS1 G - 107.1
Simon HolmstromRW - 117.0
Nicolas RoyC1 PTS1 A - 126.8
Jake McCabeD
Team stats

Player of the game
Matthew Schaefer
NYI · 2 G, 2 SOG
Deserved to win
Maple Leafs deserved better: 53% on chances, lost 3-4
Play by play
- End of the overtime
- GOALOT 4:11


Goal! Snap shot
M. Schaefer · 2 G
Matthew Schaefer Goal (12) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (22), Emil Heineman (7)
TOR 3 - 4 NYI - OT 3:52


Wrist shot on goal
Tony DeAngelo Wrist Shot saved by Joseph Woll
T. DeAngelo · 1 A
- OT 2:06


Shot blocked by J. Drouin
Auston Matthews shot blocked by Jonathan Drouin
A. Matthews · 2 G
- OT 1:38


Snap shot wide left
Matthew Knies Snap Shot Wide Left
M. Knies
- OT 1:05


Tip-in wide left
Matias Maccelli Tip-In Wide Left
M. Maccelli
- OT 0:00


Faceoff win vs M. Barzal
John Tavares faceoff won against Mathew Barzal
J. Tavares
- Start of the overtime
- End of the 3rd period
- P3 0:25

TOGiveaway
Giveaway by Anders Lee
A. Lee
- P3 0:33


Snap shot on goal
Scott Laughton Snap Shot saved by David Rittich
S. Laughton
- P3 0:53

TOGiveaway
Giveaway by Morgan Rielly
- P3 1:00


Shot blocked by M. Barzal
Max Domi shot blocked by Mathew Barzal
M. Domi · 1 A
- P3 2:02


Shot blocked by M. Gatcomb
Troy Stecher shot blocked by Marc Gatcomb
T. Stecher
- P3 2:27


Shot blocked by A. Pelech
Troy Stecher shot blocked by Adam Pelech
T. Stecher
- P3 2:45


Faceoff win vs J. Tavares
Casey Cizikas faceoff won against John Tavares
C. Cizikas
- GOALP3 2:45


Goal! Snap shot
E. Heineman · 1 G, 1 A
Emil Heineman Goal (13) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (21), Tony DeAngelo (13)
TOR 3 - 3 NYI - P3 3:47


Big hit on C. Cizikas
Simon Benoit hit Casey Cizikas
S. Benoit
- P3 4:14


Big hit on M. Rielly
Marc Gatcomb hit Morgan Rielly
M. Gatcomb
- P3 4:49


Big hit on J. Tavares
Matthew Schaefer hit John Tavares
M. Schaefer · 2 G
- P3 5:23


Shot blocked by B. McMann
Tony DeAngelo shot blocked by Bobby McMann
T. DeAngelo · 1 A
- P3 5:42


Big hit on J. Drouin
Simon Benoit hit Jonathan Drouin
S. Benoit
- P3 5:45

TOGiveaway
Giveaway by Auston Matthews
A. Matthews · 2 G
- P3 5:52


Big hit on M. Benning
Jean-Gabriel Pageau hit Matthew Benning
J. Pageau · 1 A
- P3 5:52


Wrist shot wide left
Adam Pelech Wrist Shot Wide Left
A. Pelech · 1 G
Leaders
Ask about this game
Season seriesNYI lead series 1-0
Penguins19-12-94
Red Wings24-15-41Final
Mammoth19-20-31
Devils22-17-24Final
Sabres21-15-41
Blue Jackets18-16-65Final
Flyers21-12-75
Oilers20-16-62Final
Canadiens22-13-60
Blues17-18-82Final
Lightning25-13-37
Sharks20-18-33Final
Jets15-21-42
Senators20-15-54Final
Blackhawks16-18-73
Capitals21-15-62Final/SO
Avalanche31-2-75
Hurricanes24-14-33Final
Predators19-18-44
Flames18-19-43Final

