Skip to content
Image

Edinburgh City vs Montrose

FA Cup
Edinburgh City
1-3-8
1-5
Final
Montrose
6-0-5
Meadowbank Stadium

Match pulse

EDIAttacking pressure by 5 minutes
0'HTMON
22'Robbie LeitchEDI27'Callum CraneEDI27'Liam CallaghanMON29'Michael GardyneMON66'Kelsey EwenEDI69'Scott MercerEDI79'Lee HamiltonEDI
Team1H2HT
EDI101
MON235

Who won: Montrose 5-1

Montrose beat Edinburgh City 5-1 on Saturday, November 4, 2023 at Meadowbank Stadium. Goals for Edinburgh City: Kerr Waddell (own goal) (33'). Goals for Montrose: Luke Graham (8'), Kane Hester (19'), Michael Gardyne (69' pen), Miller Thomson (72') and Craig Brown (88').

Every player rated

Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0
  1. 16.3Cameron GillG
  2. 26.3Luke GrahamCD-L
  3. 36.3Kerr WaddellCD-R
  4. 46.3Andrew SteevesLB
  5. 56.3Ryan WilliamsonRB
  6. 66.3Michael GardyneCM
  7. 76.3Liam CallaghanLM
  8. 86.3Miller ThomsonRM
  9. 96.3Kane HesterF
  10. 106.3Blair LyonsLF
  11. 116.3Matheus MachadoRF
  12. 126.0Kieran MacDonaldSUB

Player of the game

Cameron Gill

MON · 90'

6.3

Play by play

  1. Match ends, Edinburgh City 1, Montrose 5.
  2. Second Half ends, Edinburgh City 1, Montrose 5.
  3. 89'

    Foul by Russell McLean (Edinburgh City).

  4. 89'

    Free kick won

    Ali Shrive (Montrose) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  5. GOAL88'

    Goal! Left footed shot

    C. Brown

    Goal! Edinburgh City 1, Montrose 5. Craig Brown (Montrose) left footed shot from outside the box to the bottom right corner. Assisted by Graham Webster.

    EDI 1 - 5 MON
  6. 87'

    Foul by Russell McLean (Edinburgh City).

  7. 87'

    Free kick won

    Craig Brown (Montrose) wins a free kick on the left wing.

  8. 86'

    Foul by Paul Watson (Montrose).

  9. 86'

    Free kick won

    Danny Handling (Edinburgh City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  10. 85'
    Sub

    Subbed on for K. Waddell

    Substitution, Montrose. Paul Watson replaces Kerr Waddell.

    P. Watson

  11. 85'
    Sub

    Subbed on for M. Thomson

    Substitution, Montrose. Aidan Quinn replaces Miller Thomson.

    A. Quinn

  12. 82'
    Sub

    Subbed on for R. Mahon

    Substitution, Edinburgh City. Sam Gormley replaces Robbie Mahon.

    S. Gormley

  13. 82'
    Sub

    Subbed on for I. Murray

    Substitution, Edinburgh City. Liam Fontaine replaces Innes Murray.

    L. Fontaine

  14. 81'

    Free kick won

    Scott Mercer (Edinburgh City) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  15. 81'

    Foul by Kane Hester (Montrose).

  16. 80'

    Attempt missed. Craig Brown (Montrose) left footed shot from outside the box is too high.

  17. 79'

    Yellow card

    Lee Hamilton (Edinburgh City) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.

    L. Hamilton

  18. 78'

    Free kick won

    Miller Thomson (Montrose) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  19. 78'

    Foul by Lee Hamilton (Edinburgh City).

  20. 78'
    Sub

    Subbed on for L. Callaghan

    Substitution, Montrose. Ali Shrive replaces Liam Callaghan.

    A. Shrive

  21. 78'
    Sub

    Subbed on for M. Gardyne

    Substitution, Montrose. Craig Brown replaces Michael Gardyne.

    C. Brown

  22. 76'

    Foul by Blair Lyons (Montrose).

  23. 76'

    Free kick won

    Danny Handling (Edinburgh City) wins a free kick on the right wing.

  24. 74'

    Corner, Edinburgh City. Conceded by Michael Gardyne.

  25. GOAL72'

    Goal! Left footed shot

    M. Thomson

    Goal! Edinburgh City 1, Montrose 4. Miller Thomson (Montrose) left footed shot from the centre of the box to the top right corner. Assisted by Kerr Waddell.

    EDI 1 - 4 MON

Leaders

EDIMON
Total Shots
-
Kane Hester
5
Saves
-
Cameron Gill
1

Season seriesSeries tied 1-1-3

More FA Cup games on November 4