Skip to content
Image

York City vs Rotherham United, Rotherham United win 5-4 on penalties

FA Cup
York City
0-1-1
1-1
Final/Pens
Rotherham
0-1-2
Rotherham United win 5-4 on penalties
LNER Community Stadium

Match pulse

YORKAttacking pressure by 5 minutes
0'HTROT
56%Possession44%
11Shots8
2On target1
8Corners1
0Saves1
13Fouls8
50'Ashley PalmerYORK
Team1H2HET1ET2PKT
YORK100041
ROT010051

Who won: Rotherham 1-1

Rotherham United beat York City 1-1 on penalties in Rotherham United win 5-4 on penalties on Tuesday, September 22, 2026 at LNER Community Stadium. Goals for York City: Zech Medley (44'). Goals for Rotherham: Jili Buyabu (57').

Every player rated

Chirp Rating, 3.0 to 10.0
  1. 17.2Jili BuyabuLM
  2. 26.8Zech MedleyLM
  3. 36.7Arthur ReadCM-L
  4. 46.6Marvin KaletaRM
  5. 56.2Emmanuel AdegboyegaCD-L
  6. 66.1Frankie MaguireCF-L
  7. 76.1Jovan MalcolmCF-R
  8. 86.1Ben FarrarSUB
  9. 96.1Aaron NemaneSUB
  10. 106.1Ossama AshleySUB
  11. 116.0Charlie McarthurCD-L
  12. 126.0Jack HuntCD-R

Team stats

YORKROT
13Fouls8
1Yellow Cards0
0Red Cards0
2Offsides3
8Corner Kicks1
0Saves1
56Possession44
11SHOTS8
2ON GOAL1
0.2On Target %0.1
0Penalty Goals0
0Penalty Kicks Taken0
438Accurate Passes365
544Passes428
0.8Pass Completion %0.9
0Accurate Crosses0
0Crosses0
0.0Cross %0.0
0Long Balls0
0Accurate Long Balls0
0.0Long Balls %0.0
6Blocked Shots2
14Effective Tackles10
19Tackles19
0.7Tackle %0.5
0Interceptions0
0Effective Clearances0
10Clearances25

Player of the game

Jili Buyabu

ROT · 1 G

7.2

Play by play

  1. SCORE97'

    Jili Buyabu (Rotherham United) Penalty - Scored at 97'

    Jili Buyabu

    YORK 5 - 6 ROT
  2. SCORE96'

    Ben Farrar (York City) Penalty - Scored at 96'

    Ben Farrar

    YORK 5 - 5 ROT
  3. SCORE96'
    Denzel Hall

    Denzel Hall (Rotherham United) Penalty - Scored at 96'

    Denzel Hall

    YORK 4 - 5 ROT
  4. 95'

    Penalty - missed

    Jovan Malcolm (York City) Penalty - Missed at 95'

  5. SCORE94'

    Joseph Rafferty (Rotherham United) Penalty - Scored at 94'

    Joseph Rafferty

    YORK 4 - 4 ROT
  6. SCORE94'

    Ethan Stiver (York City) Penalty - Scored at 94'

    Ethan Stiver

    YORK 4 - 3 ROT
  7. SCORE93'

    Jayce Fitzgerald (Rotherham United) Penalty - Scored at 93'

    Jayce Fitzgerald

    YORK 3 - 3 ROT
  8. SCORE92'

    Dipo Akinyemi (York City) Penalty - Scored at 92'

    Dipo Akinyemi

    YORK 3 - 2 ROT
  9. SCORE91'

    Paul Mullin (Rotherham United) Penalty - Scored at 91'

    Paul Mullin

    YORK 2 - 2 ROT
  10. SCORE91'

    Arthur Read (York City) Penalty - Scored at 91'

    Arthur Read

    YORK 2 - 1 ROT
  11. 90'+1'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Lewis Beadle (York City) Substitution at 90'+1'

    L. Beadle

  12. 73'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Luka Ozisik (York City) Substitution at 73'

    L. Ozisik

  13. 72'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Oliver Belleh (York City) Substitution at 72'

    O. Belleh

  14. 70'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Paul Mullin (Rotherham United) Substitution at 70'

    P. Mullin

  15. 70'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Ossama Ashley (Rotherham United) Substitution at 70'

    O. Ashley

  16. GOAL57'

    Goal!

    J. Buyabu

    Jili Buyabu (Rotherham United) Goal at 57'

    YORK 1 - 1 ROT
  17. 50'

    Yellow card

    Ashley Palmer (York City) Yellow Card at 50'

    A. Palmer

  18. 45'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Joshua Austerfield (Rotherham United) Substitution at 45'

    J. Austerfield

  19. 45'+7'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Aaron Nemane (Rotherham United) Substitution at 45'+7'

    A. Nemane

  20. GOAL44'

    Goal!

    Z. Medley

    Zech Medley (York City) Goal at 44'

    YORK 1 - 0 ROT
  21. 43'
    Sub

    Substitution

    Ben Farrar (York City) Substitution at 43'

    B. Farrar

  22. 36'Denzel Hall
    Sub

    Substitution

    Denzel Hall (Rotherham United) Substitution at 36'

    D. Hall

Leaders

YORKROT
Total Shots
Zech Medley
2
Jili Buyabu
4
Accurate Passes
Charlie Mcarthur
75
Hamish Douglas
63
Defensive Interventions
Joel Felix
5
Emmanuel Adegboyega
9
Saves
-
Ted Cann
1

Season seriesSeries tied 1-1-3